Perkins PsyCare

Mental Health & Relationships

Your Heart Isn't Overreacting.
It's Protecting You.

Betrayal doesn't just hurt your feelings — it shocks your nervous system. Here's what's actually happening in your body, and what real healing looks like.

✍️ Dr. Monika Diaz, PhD 📖 8 min read 🧠 Betrayal Trauma

Pause. Read this slowly.

The moment you found out, two things died at once — what was, and who you thought you were. Both losses are real. Both deserve to be grieved.

You found something you weren't supposed to find. Or someone said something — casually, carelessly — and it landed like a stone through glass. Maybe you were just scrolling, or walking past a screen, or sitting across the table at dinner, and then everything shifted.

And now you're trying to act normal. You're making coffee, answering emails, laughing at the right moments. But inside? Your chest feels like it's caving in. Your mind is replaying it on a loop you can't stop. Your heart — and I mean that literally, physically — feels heavy. Tangled. Like something inside is pulling in two directions at once and neither one wins.

Here's what I want you to know before we go any further: you are not being dramatic. What you're feeling is real. It has a name. And there is a way through it.

"Between 30% and 60% of people who experience significant betrayal develop symptoms indistinguishable from PTSD — anxiety, intrusive thoughts, hypervigilance, the works. This isn't heartbreak. This is trauma."

Why Betrayal Hits Different Than Other Pain

You've been hurt before. You've had disappointments, losses, hard conversations. But this feels different — and there's a psychological reason for that.

Betrayal isn't just about what happened. It's about who did it. When someone we trust — a partner, a friend, a family member — violates that trust, our nervous system doesn't process it the same way it processes, say, a car accident or a job loss. It processes it as a fundamental rupture in safety.

In my practice, I see this constantly. People come in saying, "I know it's over, I know I should move on — so why can't I stop shaking?" Because your body doesn't care what you know. Your body only cares what it felt.

Betrayal trauma affects three areas of the brain associated with the physiological stress response: the hippocampus, the amygdala, and the prefrontal cortex. When those regions get hijacked, your ability to think clearly, regulate emotion, and feel safe — even in your own skin — gets disrupted. That's not weakness. That's neuroscience.

87%

of betrayed people report significant self-blame

60%

experience PTSD-level symptoms after major betrayal

84%

describe anger more intense than anything felt before

The "I'm Fine" Performance — And Why It Costs You

Something to sit with

Performing "I'm fine" doesn't heal you. It just postpones the bill — and the interest is brutal.

You know the performance I'm talking about. The one where you smile, you function, you say "I'm okay, just tired" — while internally you're white-knuckling your way through every hour.

There's a reason people do this, and it's not because they're in denial (well, not entirely). Our bodies can trigger fight, flight, freeze, or fawn responses — all of which are automatic, unconscious physical reactions designed to help us survive a threat. The fawn response — immediately trying to appear calm and accommodating to avoid further conflict — is incredibly common after betrayal. You go along to get along. You perform okay. You protect yourself by making yourself invisible.

But here's the cost: emotions that get pushed down don't dissolve. They go underground. And underground pressure eventually has to go somewhere — into anxiety, physical tension, emotional numbness, or sudden explosions of grief at the most inconvenient moments (ask me how I know).

Because of the nervous system's role in betrayal, you can't simply think your way back to safety. Healing requires time, consistency, and the gradual dismantling of threat responses in the body. Which means: the performance has to stop eventually. Not all at once. But it has to stop.

Your Body Knows Before Your Mind Catches Up

Brain imaging studies show that betrayal activates the same neural regions as physical pain. Let that sink in for a second. When you say "it feels like I was punched in the chest," you're not being metaphorical. Your brain is literally registering that experience as a physical wound.

This is why you might feel it in your body before your brain has fully processed it — the tight stomach, the inability to eat, the sudden crying in the shower, the way you wake up at 3 AM and it takes exactly 1.3 seconds before the thing you're trying not to think about slams back into your awareness.

The nervous system treats betrayal as a threat — even after the threat has objectively passed. This means you might logically know your situation has changed, but your body may still feel unsafe. That mismatch isn't a sign that you're broken. It's a sign that your nervous system is doing exactly what it was designed to do: keep you from getting hurt again.

"You are not weak for feeling this deeply. You loved deeply. And your nervous system is honoring the size of that love by refusing to just... let it go."

What Healing Actually Looks Like (Hint: It's Messy)

I'm going to be real with you about something most wellness content glosses over: healing from betrayal is not linear. You will have a good week and then a terrible Tuesday. You will feel like you've moved past something and then a song, a smell, a random Tuesday will drag you back. That's not failure. That's how trauma heals.

Research shows that when people are exposed to a trauma and PTSD framework to explain the effects of betrayal, they report feeling clarity, validation, and relief — because suddenly the intensity of what they're experiencing makes sense. You don't feel like you're losing your mind anymore. You feel like a person who went through something real and is processing it accordingly.

Here's what real healing tends to look like, stage by stage:

Acknowledge the wound — out loud

Name what happened. Not minimized, not softened with "but maybe they didn't mean it." Just: this happened, it hurt me, and I'm allowed to feel exactly what I feel. This sounds simple. It is one of the hardest steps.

Give your nervous system something concrete

Your body is stuck in threat mode. It needs safety signals: consistent sleep, movement, being around people who feel safe. Not toxic positivity — just the basics that tell your nervous system the acute danger has passed.

Build your narrative — on your terms

Part of healing involves developing a coherent story of the betrayal: what happened, why it might have happened, and what it means for you. This doesn't mean excusing anything. It means making sense of it in a way that gives you the pen back.

Learn to tolerate the emotions — not outrun them

Research shows that the ability to tolerate and process difficult emotions is one of the strongest predictors of healing and eventually of forgiveness. You don't have to like the feelings. You don't have to rush them. You just have to stop fleeing from them.

Rebuild trust — starting with yourself

Betrayal trauma can significantly affect both self-esteem and the ability to form future intimate relationships. So one of the most radical things you can do is practice trusting your own instincts again. Your gut knew something was wrong. Honor that. It's how you rebuild.

Let this land

Healing doesn't mean the betrayal didn't happen. It means it no longer gets to decide who you are.

On Forgiveness — The Part Nobody Wants to Hear

I know. I know. The word "forgiveness" makes people close a tab. So let me tell you what forgiveness is not: it is not saying what happened was okay. It is not a gift you give the person who hurt you. It is not required for healing.

What forgiveness actually is — if and when you arrive there, in your own time — is the decision to stop letting someone else's actions run your nervous system. It's you taking back the controls.

Forgiveness has been consistently identified as a key facilitator of healing following betrayal — but it's fundamentally an emotion-focused process, not a moral obligation. You can't logic yourself into it. You can't perform it. You have to feel your way there — slowly, messily, on your own timeline.

And some of you won't go there, and that is okay too. You can heal without forgiving. You just have to be honest with yourself about which you're doing.

When to Get Help (And Why "Talking to a Friend" Isn't Enough)

I love a good vent session with a trusted friend. I believe in it. But if you've been in survival mode for weeks, if you can't sleep, if you're replaying everything on a loop and it's not getting quieter — that's a nervous system that needs clinical support, not just comfort.

When betrayal is severe or involves someone central to your emotional world, it can create symptoms similar to PTSD — and professional support is especially important in those cases. A good therapist doesn't just listen. They help you rewire the threat response. They help you build a narrative that makes sense. They give you a safe relationship to practice trusting again — one where no one is going to lie to you, cheat, or disappear.

That matters more than most people realize. Sometimes healing is just learning that not every person you trust is going to hurt you. You have to experience that to believe it again.

"You were not naive for trusting. You were not stupid for loving. You were human — and that part of you is still worth protecting."

Dr. Monika Diaz, PhD

Perkins PsyCare

You Don't Have to Carry This Alone.

If this resonated with you — if you recognized yourself in any of this — we want you to know that support is here. Betrayal trauma is real, treatable, and something no one should have to navigate without guidance. We're here whenever you're ready.

Reach Out to Us →

Enjoyed this article?